What Makes a Good Pet Sitter? Questions to Ask Before You Book

Leaving your pet in someone else's care is a big deal—whether you're heading out for a weekend trip or an extended vacation. A good pet sitter doesn’t just feed and walk your furry friend; they offer comfort, companionship, and peace of mind while you're away.

So how do you find the right person for the job? Here’s what makes a great pet sitter, along with the top questions you should ask before booking.

Qualities of a Great Pet Sitter

1. Genuine Love for Animals

   This one might seem obvious, but it’s the foundation. A great pet sitter truly enjoys being around animals and treats each pet like their own.

2. Experience with a Variety of Pets

   Whether it’s cats, dogs, birds, or reptiles, a good sitter should have hands-on experience and comfort handling different types of pets.

3. Responsibility & Reliability

   Your pet’s routine matters. Look for someone who is punctual, communicates clearly, and respects your home and your pet’s schedule.

4. Pet First Aid Knowledge

   Emergencies can happen. A great sitter should know how to respond if a pet becomes ill or injured, and have basic first aid training.

   
   

❓Questions to Ask Before You Book

Here’s a checklist of smart questions to ask during your first call or meet-and-greet:

🐕 Experience & Background

• How long have you been pet sitting?

• What types of pets have you cared for?

• Are you insured or bonded?

• Do you have training in pet CPR or first aid?

  
  

🛏️ Services & Schedule

• What services do you provide (e.g., walks, playtime, overnight stays)?

• How many pets do you sit for at one time?

• Will you be the only person caring for my pet?

• What does a typical visit look like?

  
  

📸 Communication & Updates

• Will you send daily updates or photos?

• How do you handle emergencies or vet visits?

• Are you comfortable administering medication, if needed?

  
  

🐾 Pet Comfort

• How do you get to know a pet’s personality?

• How do you handle shy, anxious, or reactive pets?

• What’s your approach to discipline or behavioral issues?

Final Tip: Do a Trial Run

Before committing to a long trip, consider booking a short walk or drop-in visit to see how your pet and the sitter interact. It’s a great way to build trust on both sides.

Your pet is family, and they deserve someone who sees them the same way. By asking the right questions and trusting your instincts, you can find a sitter who makes being away just a little easier—for both of you.

Need a trusted, local sitter? Contact us today to learn more about our pet sitting services and schedule a meet-and-greet!

Credit to Philly's Paws & Claws LLC.